UK government weighs cut to legal cost caps for environmental groups
Lawyers warn that removing cost protections under the Aarhus convention would make it harder for communities to challenge planning decisions.
By Layla Haddad ·

The UK government is considering changes that would reduce the financial safety nets available to groups challenging environmental planning decisions. These changes target the cost caps established under the Aarhus convention, a treaty the UK ratified in 2005. The current rules limit the amount individuals and organizations must pay if they lose a legal case about environmental issues.
Under the existing treaty, an individual who loses a claim is protected by a cap of £5,000 on the other side's costs. Organizations face a cap of £10,000. The Ministry of Justice has held private meetings with select stakeholders regarding plans to remove these protections. Other proposed changes include doubling cost caps at each stage of a legal challenge. Officials are also considering removing cost protections entirely if a court finds a misuse of judicial review. A separate proposal would allow crowdfunded groups to face costs of up to 70 percent of the money they raised if they lose.
These proposals align with statements made by Prime Minister Keir Starmer, who has described nature as a blocker to growth. He cited Dr. Andrew Boswell, an activist who fought a two-year legal battle against the expansion of the A47 in Norfolk. Boswell, who lost the case, said his campaign was funded by £73,000 from 2,000 individuals. He stated that Starmer was putting a target on his back and that the fight brought the community together.
Legal experts argue the changes would discourage litigation. Carol Day, a senior environmental solicitor at Leigh Day, said the moves would bring environmental litigation almost to a halt. She noted that the government has not provided hard evidence that legal action is holding development back. Another lawyer described the proposals as a deliberate undermining of access to environmental justice. Sarah Finch, whose group successfully challenged an oil well in Surrey, said the new rules would have prevented her team from bringing the case. She called the government's plan despicable because it restricts access to environmental justice.
Kyle Lischak of ClientEarth UK emphasized the need for an affordable route to court. He noted that people often find their rights threatened by rapid industrial buildout, such as datacenters or livestock production. Niall Toru of Friends of the Earth said the government is looking for someone to blame for slow growth. He argued that nature is not holding the economy back, citing costs from floods, droughts, and pollution.
A government spokesperson said the UK is committed to upholding its obligations under the Aarhus convention. The spokesperson stated that there are no plans to remove cost protections for well-founded claims. Lawyers remain concerned that the private meetings signal an acceleration toward leaving the convention, a move the government currently denies.
The Ministry of Justice continues to consult on these changes. The outcome will determine whether community groups retain the current cost caps when challenging planning decisions that affect local nature.






