Butler argues Democratic midterm wins will not end academic anti-Zionism
The philosopher told a Boston audience that the party's centrist base retains enough power to maintain pressure on scholars and workers who oppose Zionism.
By Anthony Rivera ·

Judith Butler, a prominent academic and gender theorist, told a Boston University audience on Thursday that the recent Democratic Party victories would not immediately end the professional risks faced by those who hold anti-Zionist views. She argued that the party's large base of centrist Zionists ensures that political pressure on academia and the workforce will persist despite the election results.
Butler delivered her remarks during a keynote speech at a symposium dedicated to Jewish anti-Zionism. The event coincided with the launch of the book Jewish Anti-Zionism: A Historical Anthology, edited by Shaul Magid and Zev Mishell. She described the current political climate as one where individuals risk their education, employment, and privacy if they support anti-Zionism, particularly if they are precarious workers.
"We cannot begin a discussion of anti-Zionism without a discussion of academic freedom," Butler said. She cautioned against assuming that the "blue wave" of Democratic candidates would quickly alter the situation, noting that the party includes a vast number of Zionist centrist Democrats.
The Democratic Party has grown more hostile toward Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government, and several anti-Zionist politicians won seats in Congress in last week's midterms. Butler characterized anti-Zionism as a persecuted ideology, claiming the US government had labeled opponents of fascism and Zionism as domestic terrorists. She cited a 2025 Columbia University report that found its Middle East studies department lacked faculty who were not explicitly anti-Zionist.
In her speech, Butler described Zionism as inherently eliminationist and genocidal toward Palestinians. She rejected the link between antisemitism and anti-Zionism, arguing that Zionism's systemic racism opposed Jewish values. She accused Israelis of sadistic and murderous exhilaration in Gaza and described the ongoing conflict as a continuing Nakba, the Palestinian term for the catastrophe of 1948.
Butler stated that the right of return for Palestinians grows stronger with every dispossession. She rejected a focus that makes Jewish people the central actors, a view she called a Zionist effect. She also rejected a binational solution without prior decolonization, proposing that Palestine be constituted as a self-governing state with an Arab majority but full rights for Jewish people.
Shaul Magid, one of the book's editors, argued at the symposium that the history of Jewish anti-Zionism had been intentionally erased. He said the goal of the anthology was to erase that erasure. Magid noted that Hamas's October 7, 2023, attack and the ensuing war in Gaza caused long-buried anti-Zionist ideas to resurface. He concluded that non-Zionism was not a practical position for Jews because Zionism has become so ubiquitous in the Jewish psyche that an engaged Jewish life requires an opinion about it.






