Brooklyn Collapse: Missing Bracing Questions
City records show excavation plans near a fatal collapse lacked required steel supports for an adjacent apartment building.
By Jessica Morgan ·

A three-story apartment building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue collapsed Wednesday in Brooklyn, killing eight people and injuring 18. The incident has raised urgent questions about the city-approved engineering plans for the adjacent excavation site at 2625 Bedford Avenue.
Building records indicate that the approved support of excavation plans did not require crews to install steel buttresses, known as rakers, to support the foundation of the collapsed building. Instead, the plans called for cutting into the soil at a 45-degree angle to a depth of roughly 15 feet. This was the only location on the construction perimeter where reinforcing steel was not mandated for adjacent structures.
Three structural engineers who reviewed the documents expressed surprise that the Department of Buildings approved the strategy without additional shoring. Abi Agheyere, a professor at Drexel University, described the lack of support as a recipe for disaster. He noted that the 94-year-old building sat on a rubble foundation and that pre-construction reports by engineering firm Quiver League had flagged the facade as being in poor condition with noticeable cracks.
Chris Cerino, past president of the Structural Engineers Association of New York, stated he would have anticipated underpinning or different detailing on that side of the site. The project engineer, Jieming Wang of LMW Engineering, submitted the original plans for a three-story structure in December 2025. The development team later sought to build a nine-story complex in September, though the city had not yet approved the revised proposal.
Department of Buildings spokesperson Andrew Rudansky defended the approved plans as standard industry practice. He stated that similar excavation designs have been safely performed across the city for decades. Rudansky added that the project engineer is responsible for confirming safety before submission, and the department’s full plan exam found the designs complied with city requirements. Investigators are now reviewing the geotechnical report prepared by Michael Karantinidis of International Geotechnical/Structural Laboratories Inc.
The collapse occurred after the city issued a stop-work order earlier in the year, which the development team had previously ignored. Following Wednesday’s incident, the buildings department issued a full stop-work order and attributed the collapse to unsafe construction operations in a comment later deleted from its portal. Special inspector MD Islam, who was contracted to monitor the excavation, has requested to withdraw from the project.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced on Friday that the inquiry has expanded to 160 properties involving six different entities. The city is conducting sweep inspections at other sites where the same contractors have worked. Carpenter’s Union Executive Secretary-Treasurer Paul Capurso suggested that crews may have dug too deeply to prepare for the unapproved nine-story design rather than the approved three-story structure.
Eugene Gurevich of RAND Engineering & Architecture noted that steel reinforcement is not always required if excavation is done properly and does not dig under the foundation. He compared the building structure to a ladder, explaining that removing one leg can pull the entire structure down. The Department of Buildings is currently investigating the cause alongside the city’s Department of Investigation and the Brooklyn District Attorney’s office.






