New Task Force Reopens Investigation Into 1995 Vanishing of Robin Murphy
Carmel police and other agencies have formed a group to review evidence from the case of the 17-year-old who disappeared from a New York shopping center.
By Jessica Morgan ·

Robin Murphy, a 17-year-old from Carmel, New York, disappeared on April 9, 1995, while working at a local shopping center. More than three decades later, a multi-agency task force has been established to reinvestigate the case. The group was recently formed to review the evidence and interview key witnesses again.
Murphy met with a friend at the shopping center before failing to return home. Her brother, Jamie Murphy, recalled receiving a call at work informing him that his sister had not arrived at their family home. He stated that he felt something was wrong immediately after learning of her absence.
On April 13, 1995, four days after the disappearance, a group of civilians organized a search of the woods behind a ShopRite supermarket. Searchers located Murphy's work schedule and a paystub. Shortly after, her wallet and identification card were found near a dumpster situated behind the same shopping center.
Carmel police canvassed the area and spoke with Murphy's coworkers. This investigation led them to interview Howard Gombert, a man who worked at a laundromat within the shopping complex. Gombert and Murphy had become friends through Gombert's girlfriend at the time.
In 1995, Gombert told police he met Murphy for ten minutes the night she vanished. He claimed she walked toward a fast food restaurant where her boyfriend was employed before he returned to the laundromat. He denied knowing anything about her fate.
Gombert became a person of interest in 2000 after being convicted of sexually assaulting his former girlfriend. He received a four-year prison sentence for that crime. He was later convicted of sexually assaulting a seven-year-old girl in Connecticut and received a total sentence of 30 years for both offenses. During a search of his residence, police discovered a tan suitcase containing Ziploc bags filled with women's underwear.
Forensic tests confirmed that one piece of the underwear matched Murphy's DNA. Gombert has denied that the item belonged to him or that he obtained it from Murphy. He has offered varying explanations for other seized items, including jewelry and handbags, sometimes claiming they came from a thrift store. Police publicly identified him as a suspect in 2000, but no formal charges were ever filed.
Gombert is scheduled for release from prison no later than January 2027. In an email sent to ABC's 20/20 program, he denied any involvement in Murphy's disappearance. The new task force issued a statement acknowledging the family's desire for answers. Jamie Murphy said the search for his sister continues, describing the process as an emotional rollercoaster that he does not wish on anyone.






