McMurtry Challenges Warwick in District 5 Over Budget Control
Former council aide Scott McMurtry targets Barb Warwick, framing the 2027 race as a clash between fiscal restraint and progressive spending.
By Jessica Morgan ·

Scott McMurtry formally announced his candidacy for Pittsburgh City Council District 5 on Thursday, setting up a direct challenge to incumbent Barb Warwick in the 2027 municipal election. McMurtry, a Greenfield resident who served as chief of staff for District 8 Councilor Erika Strassburger until this spring, positions himself as a budget hawk in a city facing precarious finances. He stated that he is running to build a government that can solve problems and build big things, rather than just pontificate.
The first key point of contention is the city’s budget crisis. McMurtry’s campaign statement notes that while Pittsburgh is heading in the right direction, the ongoing fiscal issues threaten its ability to serve residents. He argues that restoring capacity and trust in governance is essential. Warwick, who is serving her first term, has supported measures like a 2% tax on unearned income, including rents and dividends, and has recently acted as a dissenting voice on a council largely aligned with Mayor Corey O’Connor.
A second major difference lies in the approach to downtown development. McMurtry supports a controversial tax subsidy approved this summer that finances Downtown improvements using future property tax revenue. He calls the potential decline of downtown an existential crisis and the cornerstone of the tax base. Warwick opposed the plan, joining two other council members in arguing that the city should focus on improvements that benefit residents more directly.
The third point of friction involves the timing of the recent property tax hike. Council passed a 20 percent increase in the final days of former Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration, a move expected to generate more than $28 million for the city. Warwick supported the hike, stating it was necessary to give O’Connor the means to make the change residents voted for. McMurtry criticized the timing, describing the shift in Warwick’s stance as an about-face that many residents found problematic.
Context for the race includes the composition of District 5, which includes Greenfield, Hazelwood, Regent Square, Swisshelm Park, and parts of Squirrel Hill, Glen Hazel, Hays, Lincoln Place, and New Homestead. District 5 is expected to be a key battleground alongside District 7, where incumbent Deb Gross is stepping down. Other seats up for grabs include those held by Bobby Wilson, Bob Charland, and Khari Mosley, as well as the city controller post held by Rachael Heisler.
McMurtry’s background includes four years in Strassburger’s office, where he worked on an affordable housing policy passed this fall that incentivizes developments with affordable units. He left the council post to become the economic development director at InnovatePGH. He said he and O’Connor share a similar vision for serving residents, praising the mayor for securing $100 million in commitments from large nonprofits to acquire emergency vehicles and other assets. McMurtry said he will not hesitate to voice opposition if initiatives are out of step with district needs.
Warwick has said she intends to run for reelection, citing ongoing work to protect Hazelwood from the construction of a waste-transfer station. She credits Gainey with making big investments in the district, particularly traffic-calming infrastructure like speed bumps that have made streets safer for walking, biking, and driving. Warwick described herself as a team player with O’Connor, noting that while they do not see eye-to-eye on every issue, she is ready to work on the things they agree on.






