Federal probes of noncitizen voting continue despite court losses
The Justice Department plans to pursue criminal cases and maintain subpoenas for California counties after dropping its lawsuit over voter roll accuracy.
By Jessica Morgan ·

The Department of Justice will continue investigating suspected noncitizen voting in California, even after losing its lawsuit against the state. Attorney General Todd Blanche said at a press conference on Thursday that the department is actively working on election integrity cases and will not stop regardless of recent election results.
This follows a series of legal setbacks for the administration. In mid-October, federal officials claimed to have identified 20,000 likely noncitizens on California voter rolls. The Justice Department sued to force state officials to segregate those ballots, but a federal judge and a federal appeals court rejected the request. The Supreme Court also declined to intervene. The DOJ dropped that lawsuit last week.
Despite the loss, the administration has not rescinded subpoenas sent to several counties in the days before Election Day. These subpoenas demand records on how local officials responded to federal demands. In Sonoma County, the subpoena covers records regarding a specific individual alleged to have voted while a noncitizen. In Los Angeles County, the request includes records on how the registrar-recorder's office screens for unlawful voting.
Critics argue the federal data is flawed. A judge in Washington, D.C., ruled the night before Election Day that the Justice Department and the Department of Homeland Security lack statutory authority to distribute lists of noncitizens to election officials. That ruling also cited a violation of the Privacy Act. The government expects to appeal.
State officials have pointed to inaccuracies in the federal lists. Tricia Webber, the top election official in Santa Cruz County, noted that of 81 people listed in her county, more than half were not registered to vote. She also found dates of birth that were impossible, including one set in 2044. A separate analysis by the UCLA Voting Rights Project found that 42% of the names on the state's list of 20,000 did not appear on the current voter roll.
Local prosecutors are also moving forward. Dan Dow, the District Attorney in San Luis Obispo, is investigating 63 potential noncitizen voters flagged by federal officials. He has charged one individual so far. Dow stated that while noncitizen voting is rare, it is a crime under California law.
James Williams, the county executive for Santa Clara County, said he is prepared for the administration's continued efforts. He described the federal drive as an attempt to create facts that do not exist. Williams said local and state governments should align to facilitate voting for every citizen while ensuring rolls are accurate.






