Thanksgiving Costs: A $11.44 Gap in Store Pricing
A comparison of eight staple items reveals a wide range in total costs across four major retailers, with loyalty programs offering further discounts.
By Anthony Rivera ·

Shoppers in Hillsborough County are facing higher grocery bills as they prepare for the upcoming holiday season. The United States Department of Agriculture projects that national grocery prices will average approximately 2% higher this year than last year. This increase has prompted consumers to scrutinize their spending habits and seek out specific retail outlets to manage their budgets.
Jeanie Roberson, a local shopper, noted a perceived rise in costs at the point of sale. She stated that items appear more expensive and package sizes seem smaller. Roberson said, "To me it just seems like everything is higher and the servings are smaller. You have to watch the packaging size." She now creates detailed lists and purchases different items at different stores to mitigate the impact.
Carolene Darosa, who has been tracking prices for her Thanksgiving meal, described the current costs as "crazy." She pointed to a recent trip to Walmart where five items totaled approximately $100. To reduce her individual financial burden, Darosa is organizing a potluck-style event. She explained, "I’m having a Friendsgiving. If I had to cook everything myself, I would go crazy, so I’m making everyone cook a little something that way it’s more affordable."
To quantify the difference in retail pricing, reporter Amber Jayanth conducted a price check across Publix, Aldi, Walmart, and Kroger. The test included eight specific items: eggs, canned pumpkin, stuffing mix, green beans, sweet potatoes, rolls, gravy, and canned cranberry sauce. The investigation focused on the lowest available price for each item at each location.
Publix recorded the highest total cost for the list at $26.22. Kroger’s total was $24.50, which dropped to $19.55 for customers using a Kroger Plus card. Walmart’s total for the same items was $19.95. Aldi offered the lowest price, with a total of $14.78. The difference between the most expensive and the least expensive store amounted to $11.44.
The data suggests that store choice and the use of loyalty cards can significantly alter the final bill for a basic holiday menu. Shoppers who are willing to visit multiple locations and utilize rewards programs can reduce their expenditures. The $11.44 gap between Publix and Aldi represents a concrete difference in cost for the eight tested items.
More Business · Scam Watch · Report a business · Got a Story?






